An independent media project · Not a government service · Official advice: Be Ready (UK Government)

Handbook / Emergency Kits

5 Survival Gadgets You Might REGRET Buying!

12 November 2026 · Adapted from our film

Gerald, Margaret and Derek are fictional characters. The practical points are general information, not professional advice. In an emergency, call 999.

Gerald has received a parcel. Inside is a survival gadget described as revolutionary, military-grade and absolutely essential. It is a spoon with a compass attached. The compass points towards the spoon. Derek calls it an investment in resilience. Margaret asks how much it cost. Forty-nine pounds, plus postage. Today we're examining five emergency purchases that can disappoint people, not because every example is useless, but because the marketing often promises far more than the product can deliver. First, a warning about the format. We are not claiming to have surveyed thousands of buyers or tested particular brands. These are five categories where common trade-offs deserve scrutiny. Some products are excellent for specific users. Others are expensive solutions to problems you don't actually have. The goal is to help you ask better questions before spending money. Gerald has already asked whether he can return the spoon. The retailer says the compass is a premium feature and therefore non-refundable. Number five: the enormous pre-packed survival bag. It looks magnificent online. Dozens of items, neatly arranged, perhaps even a dramatic photograph of a mountain. But open the list and ask what each item does. Are the contents good quality? Are they legal and appropriate for the UK? Do you know how to use them? Is the bag too heavy for the person expected to carry it? A family with young children may need medication, nappies and water more urgently than a folding saw. Derek's bag contains three saws and a miniature shovel. No spare socks.

The better approach is to build around your household. Start with essential medication arrangements, water, appropriate food, lighting, phone charging, contact details and weather-suitable clothing. Add items only when they solve a real problem. A modest bag that fits and can be carried is more useful than a heroic rucksack abandoned in the hallway. Gerald tries on Derek's pack and immediately sits down. Margaret labels this a successful weight test. Number four: the miracle hand-crank power station. The advertising suggests you can power an entire house by turning a handle for a few minutes. Reality is less generous. Small hand-crank devices can be useful for emergency light or limited radio operation, but charging a modern smartphone takes energy. Human-powered generation is slow and tiring. Solar-assisted products also depend on available sunlight. Read specifications and credible independent reviews. Don't confuse a list of charging methods with an unlimited supply of electricity. Derek demonstrates his crank radio. After five minutes of vigorous turning, he has generated enough enthusiasm to frighten the cat. The radio works, which is useful. The claim that it will run Gerald's kettle is not. Margaret keeps a charged power bank and a simple radio as separate tools. Neither pretends to be a miniature power station. Sometimes two ordinary devices beat one gadget with seventeen impressive-sounding functions.

Number three: expensive emergency food nobody likes. Long-life meal buckets can suit certain circumstances, but examine portion sizes, energy content, preparation requirements, allergens, water needs and storage conditions. A label promising thirty days of food may refer to servings rather than complete balanced meals for your household. Some meals require boiling water. Some taste unfamiliar. If your family won't eat them, you have purchased a very costly cupboard ornament. Gerald's emergency mushroom risotto has a shelf life of twenty-five years. He dislikes mushrooms. A better starting point is ordinary shelf-stable food you already use. Rotate it. Build a realistic menu. Include a manual tin opener where needed. Consider dietary needs and safe food handling. You can always add specialist foods later if they solve a genuine storage or mobility problem. Derek's freeze-dried pudding requires hot water, a bowl and fifteen minutes of patience. He has brought none of those items to the demonstration. Number two: the giant portable power station bought without doing the maths. These batteries can be extremely useful, particularly for some essential low-power devices. But capacity, output, recharge time and safety matter. Watt-hours are not the same as watts. A device rated for high power may empty a small battery quickly. A kettle, heater or microwave can consume far more energy than a lamp or phone. Check actual requirements and any medical-device compatibility with appropriate professionals. Don't assume a power station can run a whole house because the photograph shows a smiling family beside one.

Gerald has purchased a battery pack to keep the television running. Margaret asks how long it will last. Gerald points at a sticker saying ONE THOUSAND WATTS. Margaret points out that this is not the same as one thousand watt-hours of usable energy. Derek suggests connecting six power stations in a pyramid. Nobody asks him to elaborate. The useful lesson is to list the devices you genuinely need, estimate consumption and buy capacity accordingly. And number one: security gadgets that make you feel safe without fixing a weak door. A camera can provide awareness and evidence. An alarm may deter or alert. Smart lighting can be useful. But none of them repairs a rotten frame, a faulty lock or an open side gate. Nor should security measures block fire exits. Start with the physical basics, then consider electronics that add value. Avoid booby traps, weapons marketed as quick fixes, and any plan based on confronting intruders. Gerald's camera has recorded the same fox every evening. The back door still doesn't latch. What unites these five purchases? They sell certainty. Buy this bag, this battery, this bucket or this gadget and the emergency is supposedly solved. Real preparedness is less glamorous. It requires maintenance, planning, safe storage and knowing your own needs. It also means checking what you already own. You may have a perfectly good torch, warm clothing, a radio and enough ordinary food to make a useful start. Derek's latest catalogue insists that all of those items need to be upgraded to tactical versions. Margaret disagrees.

Before any significant purchase, ask five questions. What exact problem will this solve? What evidence supports the claims? What will it cost to maintain? Can I use it safely? And what cheaper alternative already exists? If the seller cannot explain the product without shouting MILITARY GRADE, perhaps continue shopping. If you are buying batteries or power equipment, use reputable suppliers and follow manufacturer guidance. False economy is not resilience. And remember that regret isn't always about the product itself. Sometimes a perfectly good item was purchased for the wrong job. A compact radio is useful for receiving broadcasts, but it will not replace a mobile phone. A thermal blanket may be helpful in a specific situation, but it cannot safely heat an entire freezing house. A water filter may have a role outdoors, but it is not proof that any contaminated water is drinkable. Match the tool to the hazard, read the instructions and understand the limitations. Derek calls his shovel an all-purpose survival solution. Margaret asks whether it can recharge a phone. Derek changes the subject. Now for our final experiment. Pick one item you regret buying, or one sitting unused in a cupboard. Work out whether it can be repurposed safely, sold or donated. Then put the money or shelf space towards a real gap. Gerald has returned his compass spoon. Derek has offered to buy it at a discount. Margaret has hidden the online shopping catalogue. This is the most effective security measure implemented all week.

Which prepper purchase do you think is most overrated: giant go-bags, crank gadgets, survival food, power stations or smart security? Tell us what you've actually found useful. This has been The British Prepping Society. Preparing for the worst. Politely.

Official guidance

For the UK Government's own advice on preparing for emergencies, see Be Ready. Emergency Alerts are explained at gov.uk/alerts. Power cut in England, Scotland or Wales: call 105. Smell gas or suspect carbon monoxide: call 0800 111 999. Life in danger: call 999.

Watch the film on YouTube · Subscribe to the Society